I don't know where to start

What do I need to do, and how far from reject am I?

What to check

  1. Check the public policy at _dmarc.yourdomain and save the existing value.
  2. Inventory domains, subdomains, DNS operators and business owners.
  3. Enable and confirm aggregate reporting before making a policy decision.
  4. Ask departments about actual sending workflows, including infrequent invoices, alerts and password resets.

If an existing reject policy is working, do not weaken it simply to follow a new project plan.

Can a DNS check find every sender?

No. DNS shows published records, not every legitimate application sending with your domain. You need traffic data and departmental discovery.

Should I move an existing reject policy back to none?

Not automatically. Record the current protection, investigate any reported problem and preserve working enforcement where possible.